Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) is a behavior rating scale intended to help diagnose autism. CARS was developed by Eric Schopler, Robert J. Reichier, and Barbara Rochen Renner. CARS was designed to help differentiate children with autism from those with other developmental delays, such as mental retardation.
Although there is no gold standard among rating scales in detecting autism, CARS is frequently used as part of the diagnostic process.[1] Development of the CARS began in 1966 with the production of a scale that incorporated the criteria of Leo Kanner (1943) and Creak (1964), and characteristic symptoms of childhood autism.,[2]
Contents
- 1 CARS evaluation criteria
- 2 Childhood Autism Rating Scale
- 3 References
- 4 External links
|
CARS evaluation criteria[edit]
CARS is a diagnostic assessment method that rates children on a scale from one to four for various criteria, ranging from normal to severe, and yields a composite score ranging from non-autistic to mildly autistic, moderately autistic, or severely autistic. The scale is used to observe and subjectively rate fifteen items.
- relationship to people
- imitation
- emotional response
- body
- object use
- adaptation to change
- visual response
- listening response
- taste-smell-touch response and use
- fear and nervousness
- verbal communication
- non-verbal communication
- activity level
- level and consistency of intellectual response
- general impressions
Childhood Autism Rating Scale[edit]
This scale can be completed by a clinician or teacher or parent, based on subjective observations of the child's behavior. Each of the fifteen criteria listed above is rated with a score of:
- 1 normal for child’s age
- 2 mildly abnormal
- 3 moderately abnormal
- 4 severely abnormal
- Midpoint scores of 1.5, 2.5, and 3.5 are also used
Total CARS scores range from a fifteen to 60, with a minimum score of thirty serving as the cutoff for a diagnosis of autism on the mild end of the autism spectrum.
Initial psychometrics for the CARS were determined using 537 children enrolled in the Treatment and Education of Autistic and related Communication handicapped Children (TEACCH) program over a ten-year period (Schopler et al., 1980). Fifty-one percent of the children studied scored above the cutoff score of thirty.
Schopler et al. (1980) observed the existence of a bimodal distribution among these scores, leading them to develop criteria to differentiate between those with mild to moderate autism and those with severe autism. Children with a score exceeding 36 and who received a rating of three or greater on at least five subscales were categorized as being severely autistic.
Internal consistency of the CARS was high, with a coefficient alpha of .94 (Schopler et al., 1988), indicating the degree to which all of the fifteen scale criteria scores constitute a unitary phenomenon, rather than several individual behaviors. Inter-rater reliability was established using two raters for 280 cases. The average reliability of .71 indicated good overall agreement between raters.
Twelve-month test-retest data was also collected, with a finding that the means were not significantly different from the first testing to the second.
Criterion-related validity was determined by comparing CARS diagnoses to diagnoses made independently by child psychologists and psychiatrists. Diagnoses correlated at r = .80, which indicated that the CARS diagnosis was in agreement with clinical judgments.
CARS has also been shown to have 100% predictive accuracy when distinguishing between groups of autistic and intellectually disabled children, which was superior to the ABC and Diagnostic Checklist (Teal & Wiebe, 1986).
Validity of the CARS under different settings is of particular importance to the present study. CARS scores of 41 children taken through parent interview were compared to scores derived from direct observation. Mean scores under the two conditions were not significantly different and the correlation of r = .83 further indicated good agreement.
In addition, diagnoses based on parent interview and direct observation agreed in 90% of the cases. The authors suggest that valid CARS ratings and diagnoses can be achieved through parent interview (Schopler et al., 1988).
Of the autism rating scales discussed, the CARS is the only scale used in research with adolescents or adults. Mesibov, Schopler, Schaffer, and Michal (1989) examined the diagnostic ability of the CARS in adolescents and adults with autism. This study compared the CARS scores of 89 individuals before the age of ten (mean age of 8.7 years), with their scores after the age of thirteen (mean age of 15.9 years). Fifty-nine of the original 89 participants were diagnosed with autism before the age of ten, with a mean CARS score of 38.47. For those 59 participants, adolescent CARS scores revealed a significant decrease, with a mean score of 35.54.
Significant improvement in adolescent scores (i.e. significant decreases in abnormal behavior) were found on the imitation, body use, object use, adaptation to change, listening response, sensory response and use, verbal communication, nonverbal communication, and activity level scales. The only score with a significant increase over time was the general impression scale.
It was suggested that a cutoff score of 27, as opposed to 30, be used when administering the CARS to adolescents and adults. This recommendation stemmed from the observation that when the cutoff score was lowered by three points (corresponding to the mean difference in scores between the two age groups), the percentage of individuals accurately diagnosed as autistic before age ten and after age thirteen jumped from 81% to 92%.
Overall, Mesibov et al. (1989) suggested that the CARS is a good screening instrument for adolescents and adults. While Mesibov et al.’s (1989) study provided valuable insight into the course of the disorder over time; the generalization of the use of the CARS on adults based on its results is premature. The mean age of participants in the “adolescent and adult” age group was only 15.9 years. As a result, the study failed to demonstrate the ability of the CARS to diagnosis autism in adults (i.e. individuals over 21 years old). The CARS has been used with adults in clinical settings, but researchers have yet to verify its diagnostic ability with this population.
References[edit]
- ^ Ozonoff, S, Boodlin-Jones, B, & Solomon, M. (2005). Evidence-based assessment of Autism Spectrum Disorder in children and adolescents. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 34, 523-540.
- ^ Schopler E, Reichler RJ, DeVellis RF, Daly K (1980). "Toward objective classification of childhood autism: Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS)". J Autism Dev Disord 10 (1): 91–103. doi:10.1007/BF02408436. PMID 6927682.
External links[edit]
|
Pervasive Developmental Disorders portal |
Developmental disorders: Pervasive developmental disorders and autism spectrum (F84, 299)
|
|
Main |
- Causes
- Comorbid conditions
- Epidemiology
- Heritability
- Sociological and cultural aspects
- Therapies
|
|
Diagnoses |
- Autism spectrum (High-functioning autism
- Classic Autism
- Asperger's Syndrome
- PDD-NOS)
- Childhood disintegrative disorder
- Rett syndrome
|
|
Related conditions |
- ADHD
- Anxiety disorder
- Epilepsy
- Fragile X syndrome
- Savant syndrome
- Mental retardation
- Dyspraxia
- Multiple complex developmental disorder
|
|
Controversies |
- Autism rights movement
- Autistic enterocolitis
- MMR vaccine
- Thiomersal (Chelation)
|
|
Diagnostic scales |
- Gilliam Asperger's Disorder Scale
- Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule
- Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised
- Autism Spectrum Quotient
- Childhood Autism Rating Scale
|
|
Lists |
- Autism-related topics
- Fictional characters
- People
- Speculated historical figures
|
|
|
|
dsrd (o, p, m, p, a, d, s), sysi/epon, spvo
|
proc (eval/thrp), drug (N5A/5B/5C/6A/6B/6D)
|
|
|
|
Autism resources
|
|
- Autism
- Autism spectrum
- Outline of autism
|
|
Awareness |
- Autism friendly
- Autism Sunday
- Communication Shutdown
- World Autism Awareness Day
|
|
Culture |
- Autistic art
- Asperger syndrome in popular culture
- Autism spectrum disorders in the media
- Circle of friends
- Neurodiversity
- Sociological and cultural aspects of autism
|
|
Autism therapies
(main article) |
Medical
|
- Aripiprazole
- Arbaclofen
- Chelation therapy
- Fluoxetine
- Gluten-free, casein-free diet
- Haloperidol
- Hyperbaric oxygen therapy
- Melatonin
- Methylphenidate
- Olanzapine
- Risperidone
- Secretin
- Sertraline
- Vitamin B12
|
|
Cognitive or
behavioral
|
- Applied behavior analysis
- Lovaas technique
- Pivotal response therapy
- Empathizing–systemizing theory
|
|
Developmental models
|
- Floortime
- The P.L.A.Y. Project
- Relationship Development Intervention
- Son-Rise
|
|
Other
|
- Ethical challenges to autism treatment
- Hug machine
- Speech therapy
- Treatment and education of autistic and related communication handicapped children
|
|
|
Centers |
Research
|
- Autism Research Centre (UK)
- Autism Research Institute (US)
- National Alliance for Autism Research (US)
- TEACCH (US)
- Yale Child Study Center (US)
- See also Conditions and research areas
- Researchers
|
|
Treatment
|
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (US)
- M.I.N.D. Institute (US)
|
|
|
Organizations |
Asia
|
- Action for Autism (India)
- Autism Resource Centre (Singapore)
- GetVidya (India)
|
|
Caribbean
|
- Autistic Society Of Trinidad And Tobago
- Maia Chung Autism and Disabilities Foundation (JAM)
|
|
Europe
|
- Ambitious about Autism (UK)
- Aspies For Freedom
- Autism Anglia (UK)
- The Autism Directory (UK)
- Autism Awareness Campaign UK
- Autism Cymru (UK)
- Autism Plus (UK)
- Autistica (UK)
- Developmental Adult Neurodiversity Association (UK)
- Disability Challengers (UK)
- ESPA College (UK)
- ICT4Autism (UK)
- National Autistic Society (UK)
- Sacar (charity) (UK)
- Specialisterne (DEN)
|
|
North America
|
- Athletes Against Autism (US)
- Autism National Committee (US)
- Autism Network International (US)
- Autism Science Foundation (US)
- Autistic Self Advocacy Network (US)
- Autism Society of America (US)
- Autism Speaks (US)
- The Cody Center (US)
- The Daniel Jordan Fiddle Foundation (US)
- Filipino Canadian Autism Parent Support Group (CA)
- Generation Rescue (US)
- Interactive Autism Network (US)
- LENA Foundation (US)
- The P.L.A.Y. Project (US)
- SafeMinds (US)
- Talk About Curing Autism (US)
- TouchPoint Autism Services (US)
- Yale Child Study Center (US)
|
|
Oceania
|
- Luke Priddis Foundation (AUS)
|
|
South America
|
- Centro Ann Sullivan del Perú
|
|
International
|
- Autism rights movement
- Wrong Planet
|
|
|
Books |
Non-fiction
|
- The Accidental Teacher: Life Lessons from My Silent Son
- Aspergirls: Empowering Females with Asperger's Syndrome
- Animals in Translation
- Autism's False Prophets
- Freaks, Geeks, and Asperger Syndrome: A User Guide to Adolescence
- Like Colour to the Blind
- Look Me in the Eye
- Mother Warriors
- Overcoming Autism
- Somebody Somewhere
- Son-Rise: The Miracle Continues
- Strange Son
- Unstrange Minds
|
|
Fiction
|
- The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
- Dear John
- House Rules
- Mockingbird
- Nobody Nowhere
- Saving Max
- Speed of Dark
- Le Voyage d'Hiver
- With the Light
|
|
Child / Young adult
|
- Everybody Is Different: A Book for Young People Who Have Brothers or Sisters With Autism
- Ian's Walk: A Story about Autism
- Marcelo in the Real World
- Rage: A Love Story
- Rules
|
|
|
Journals |
- Autism
- Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders
|
|
Autism-related films
|
|
Documentary |
- Autism Every Day
- Autism Is a World
- Autism: The Musical
- Children of the Stars
- Dad's in Heaven with Nixon
- The Horse Boy
- Normal People Scare Me
- Recovered: Journeys Through the Autism Spectrum and Back
- Refrigerator Mothers
- Too Sane for This World
|
|
Docudrama/Biopic |
- After Thomas
- Cries from the Heart
- Marathon
- Son-Rise: A Miracle of Love
- Temple Grandin
- Wretches & Jabberers
|
|
Educational films |
|
|
Fictional films |
- A Child Is Waiting
- Adam
- Backstreet Dreams
- Barfi!
- Ben X
- The Black Balloon
- Bless the Child
- The Boy Who Could Fly
- Breaking and Entering
- Burning Bright
- Carne
- Change of Habit
- Chocolate
- Cube
- Dark Floors
- David's Mother
- Dear John
- Dr. Pomerantz
- Elling
- Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close
- Fly Away
- God's Ears
- House of Cards
- I Am Sam
- Imagination
- Joshua
- Joyful Noise
- Killer Diller
- Mabul
- Mario
- Mary and Max
- Mercury Rising
- Midwinter Night's Dream
- Miracle Run
- Molly
- Mozart and the Whale
- My Name Is Khan
- Nell
- Nightworld: Lost Souls
- Little Voice
- Ocean Heaven
- The Other Sister
- Quantum Apocalypse
- Raam
- Rain Man
- Relative Fear
- Run Wild, Run Free
- Salmon Fishing in the Yemen
- Silent Fall
- Simple Simon
- Snow Cake
- The Stone Boy
- The Story of Luke
- Under the Piano
- Vase de Noces
- When the Bough Breaks
- White Frog
- The Wizard
- Zig Zag
|
|
- Portal:Film
- Portal:Pervasive Developmental Disorders
- Wiktionary
- Wikibooks
- Wikiquote
- WikiSource
- Wikimedia Commons
- Wikinews
- Wikiversity
|
|